April 6, 2018 at 1:53 p.m.
Charities: Potential seen in Bush plan
"We've been providing services for years, so it's not too terribly new," said Joseph Buttigieg, associate executive director of diocesan Catholic Charities.
President Bush established the Office of Faith-Based and Community Initiatives at the White House, with offices in the departments of Justice, Labor, Health and Human Services, Education, and Housing and Urban Development. He hopes to eliminate barriers to faith-based organizations' efforts to solve society's ills.
Positives
Rev. Phil Grigsby, executive director of the ecumenical Schenectady Inner-City Ministries (SICM), agreed that "we've worked with government money for a number of years, and I think that can work well. That has not been a problem."He applauded the faith-based initiative, calling it "well-designed for community initiatives like ours that work with local churches."
SICM sponsors food pantries and cooperatives, a summer lunch program for children, the Damien Center for those affected by AIDS and HIV, a jobs program, and community advocacy.
Connection
Opponents have objected to Bush's plan on the basis of the separation of church and state, and are concerned about religious organizations accepting federal funds. But Mr. Buttigieg noted that like secular organizations, Catholic Charities has always applied for various government grants and funds to help it continue its work."We [provided services] long before government funding was available," he added. He also noted that the Church attempts to provide for the poor with or without government aid, while secular agencies that don't get funding often eliminate services.
David Hamilton, associate director for Catholic Charities for the New York State Catholic Conference, noted that "it's part of our beliefs and our value structure" for the Catholic Church to provide for the needy. (The Catholic Conference is the public policy arm of the state's bishops.)
Cooperative
"The bottom line is that faith-based organizations have and should continue to play a key role in providing services," Mr. Hamilton said. "We welcome the chance for more recognition and assistance from the government in providing these services."He cautioned, however, that agencies like Catholic Charities don't want to be seen as replacements for the government in helping people who patronize food pantries, those who deal with unexpected pregnancies and those who need financial assistance with everything from groceries to utilities.
The Church alone cannot end poverty, he said, adding that "poverty is a function of how society distributes wealth and income."
Working together
One point of argument for opponents of the President's plan is that faith-based organizations accepting federal funds will have to exhaustively prove to the government that those funds are being used for charitable efforts, not religious ones.Again, said Mr. Buttigieg, "we do that now: We have external auditors who come in and review our services extensively. We have no problem with that. We're very careful about how we spend. If they say they want this money to go to house homeless people, that's where we put the money."
Mr. Hamilton spoke of a "reciprocal relationship" between the government that funds services to the needy and the agencies that accept it.
"If we take money, we need to be accountable," he explained. "There is a sense of stewardship, of wise and appropriate use of money."
Boundaries
Mr. Hamilton noted that Catholic agencies would be concerned only if the federal government began to require that certain services be given in exchange for funding; for example, abstinence-education funding that would require giving out condoms would be refused by Catholic organizations.However, he added, "Catholic agencies don't ask people to profess their belief in the Catholic faith before we provide services."
Rev. Grigsby said that President Bush's initiative is simply a case of the federal government catching up with what's already being done locally.
"We welcome it," he told The Evangelist. "We see it as a real paradigm shift. We're glad to have this initiative."
(02-15-01) [[In-content Ad]]
MORE NEWS STORIES
- Washington Roundup: Breakdown of Trump-Musk relationship, wrongly deported man returned
- National Eucharistic Pilgrimage protests, Wisconsin Catholic Charities, Uganda terrorists thwarted | Week in Review
- Traditional Pentecost pilgrimage comes in middle of heated TLM discussion in French church
- Report: Abuse allegations and costs down, but complacency a threat
- Expectant mom seeking political asylum in US urges protection of birthright citizenship
- Living Pentecost
- The Acts of the Apostles and ‘The Amazing Race’
- Movie Review: Final Destination Bloodlines
- Movie Review: The Ritual
- NJ diocese hopes proposed law will resolve religious worker visa problems
Comments:
You must login to comment.