April 6, 2018 at 1:53 p.m.
Entertainment Column
'Joan of Arc' falls short
Joan of Arc has always been one of the more interesting and controversial saints in Church history:
* A strong person who stood up for her beliefs, even to martyrdom, she is admired by women as a model of feminine perseverance and courage. But as a military leader who chose war over peace, she is looked on askance by pacifists in the Church.
* Hailed by French Catholics as the savior of their nation, she was convicted of heresy by English Catholics and their Anglophile friends in France.
* Although she was cleared by the Church of heresy within a few years of her death, it took that same Church almost another four centuries to canonize her.
Looks right
Delving into her remarkable life is a new, four-hour TV movie, "Joan of Arc," to be shown on CBS May 16 and 18. There's a lot right about this film, including its look and casting; but in the end, it has too many flaws to be outstanding.What's very right about "Joan of Arc" are the sets and costumes. Filmed in the Czech Republic, the movie has the look of the times: The chain mail is battered, the castles are cold, the peasant towns are muddy.
And the cast looks right, too. Peter O'Toole, as the bishop who tries Joan, has a skull-face that seems to have come off a gargoyle. As a hired knight experienced in warfare, Peter Strauss looks worn out from fighting too many battles and seeing too many corpses. Playing a woman on the verge of death, Shirley MacLaine is wan and wizened. As a nun who supports Joan, Olympia Dukakis is a medieval Mother Teresa.
Flaws
In the title role, Leelee Sobieski looks the part of a peasant girl. A teenager, she is the right age for the part, giving it a verisimilitude not found in previous versions of the saint's life. She is gawky in manner, hesitant at first to take on her divinely inspired role and childish when scolded. But she is also radiant in prayer and firm in her convictions once she embraces them.All that being said, there are elements at the heart of "Joan of Arc" that make it not very moving. First of all, it's confusing. Unless you have recently studied the history and geography of France, you're going to be lost amid the discussions of Burgundy, Loire, Lorraine, Domremy and Orleans. Why the English rule France who have a king of their own remains a mystery. Without that information, viewers will spend a lot of time trying to figure out where's where and who's who.
Then there is the question of motivation. The movie does not shy from Joan's voices, but it mixes in theories of legend and fate that dilute the spiritual foundation of her life. An example occurs right at the movie's beginning when Joan at the stake is visually connected to Christ -- and then superimposed words bring in Merlin the Magician! Toward the end of the four hours, Joan seems to be saying that no one is responsible for their actions; rather, they are puppets in God's hands.
Not up to it
Finally, there is Miss Sobieski's performance. Previous Joans have been played by older actresses, who lose the physical advantage she brings but who have the acting experience she doesn't. She uses a flat tone of voice throughout "Joan of Arc" that becomes distracting.And while she is excellent in portraying Joan at prayer, she cannot achieve the anguished distress and final apotheosis required at Joan's martyrdom (which, by the way, the movie rushes through).
That a major network would devote four hours of primetime television to a saint merits credit and hosannas. You might want to watch the film just to build its ratings and encourage similar efforts. But, while it's a worthy effort, "Joan of Arc" is not an Arc of triumph.
(Two websites offer information about the film and the background of the real-life characters: cbs.com and cbsjoanofarc.com.)
(05-13-99) [[In-content Ad]]
MORE NEWS STORIES
- Inspired by millennial soon-to-be-saint, Irish teens create animated Lego-Carlo Acutis film
- Anxiety, uncertainty follow Trump travel ban
- Supreme Court rules in favor of Wisconsin Catholic agency over religious exemption
- Analysts: Trump’s action on Harvard, Columbia could have implications for religious groups
- Commission tells pope universal safeguarding guidelines almost ready
- Council of Nicaea anniversary is call to Christian unity, speakers say
- Vatican office must be place of faith, charity, not ambition, pope says
- Pope Leo XIV names Uganda-born priest as bishop of Houma-Thibodaux
- Report: Immigration data ‘much lower’ than Trump administration claims
- Religious freedom in Russia continues to decline, say experts
Comments:
You must login to comment.